www.onebee.com

Web standards alert

Account: log in (or sign up)
onebee Writing Photos Reviews About

Paradigm Shift

For the longest time, I was not a music person. My sister liked Debbie Gibson and New Kids on the Block (in accordance with legal statutes at the time), but I just didn't really pay attention to music. I had a tape of Billy Joel's "Storm Front" because I really liked "We Didn't Start the Fire" and I think I had a Michael Bolton tape because I was fond of the gospel-ish backup on "Love is a Wonderful Thing". But that was it.

Lately, I listen to music much, much more. I wouldn't say I can't live without it, but it's a much bigger part of my life. I think MP3 was a big part of the reason – my tastes are simultaneously too eclectic and too specific. Too eclectic to sample a lot of new artists, because I have no idea how to focus in on what I'll like; too specific to buy many albums, because I usually only like one or two songs out of 20. But with MP3 you can get just the song you want, and you can try a lot of songs or artists without a major investment.

Still, I don't listen to commercial radio (can't bear the commercials, but I really can't stand the DJs), so most new music I discover is through friends, movie and commercial soundtracks, or Letterman appearances I'm too lazy to fast-forward through. There's so much music out there. Sometimes I'll hear songs on Arksie's McRace poker mix, and I'll think, "Of course! I love this song! I'd forgotten all about it!" And, most times, I immediately re-forget. So many songs.

Today, faithful reader AC tipped me off to Pandora, which is a little web-based service that will build a custom radio station based on the songs or artists you input, and then you just listen to it and it introduces you to new songs that have been specifically selected to match your tastes. It's unfuckingbelievable – and that's not a word I use lightly (except in traffic). I keep worrying I'm going to strain it with my wildly varying tastes. (They Might Be Giants + Lyle Lovett + Warren Zevon + Tenacious D, etc.) So far, though, it's holding up. It keeps playing new, fun songs. Some I've never heard of. Some I already own. Some are by bands I've heard of, but I'm completely unfamiliar with. It even recommended one song because it featured a "prominent accordion part" (which isn't one of my qualifications for liking a song, but I'm impressed that the TMBG attributes are that specific!).

It's powered by something called the Music Genome Project, which is people listening to thousands of songs and specifying their attributes. Truly amazing. And it's entirely free. (You can pay to eliminate ads, but so far the ads don't interrupt the music, they just show up on the page.) You can even save tracks to your favorites for later.

The thing is, this is something that iTunes absolutely must have. Apple should be buying this thing today. Incorporating this functionality into Party Shuffle would make it unstoppable. It would eliminate the need to input your favorite bands and songs, because they're already in iTunes. It could be linked directly to the iTunes Music Store for any songs you don't already own. And the Music Genome folks could keep adding new data all the time to make it stronger. (Plus, it could take all our thumbs-up/thumbs-down ratings and aggregate the tastes of all the listeners into even stronger recommendations.)

The difficulty with selling music to people (and the appeal of illegal downloading) is that there is so much music and it's so difficult to find new music that you like without paying up front. Adding a feature like this would drive iTunes's sales through the roof, and eliminate the motivation for a lot of illegal file-sharing. Right now, most songs sold through iTunes are popular songs that everybody knows, like Coldplay or whatever. But if they had a feature like this, publicizing unknown songs from deep in the catalogue directly to people who will appreciate them, it would be a license to print money. The trick would be getting the music companies to agree to the free full-length previews, but I'm betting the sales figures would justify it.

Anyway, my entire concept of how I listen to music has been changed by this thing. Ken Nordine would call it a "paradigm shift."

12 Comments (Add your comments)

BrandonFri, 12/2/05 12:30pm

Unbefuckinglievable is right! Holy crap! This is awesome!

One question - does your station stick around after you close your browser, or do you have to re-enter your musical tastes each time?

If iTunes doesn't buy this thing, they are fools. I'm already opening up iTunes so I can add songs I like to my shopping cart, and the first one Pandora played for me was fantastic. A home run in their first at-bat. Wow. Thank you, Jameson.

BrandonFri, 12/2/05 12:42pm

Ahh, just got to the part where they have you register. Question answered. Awesomeness still unfolding before me like candy sex rainbows made of money.

Bee BoyFri, 12/2/05 1:00pm

candy sex rainbows made of money

Hellsyeah! Not just money... velvet money! And it turns out you can create multiple stations, in case you prefer your TMBG separate from your Lyle.

ACFri, 12/2/05 1:29pm

He he! So glad you like it. I always have fun introducing you to new music. For me, music is essential. I can safely say I couldn't live without it. But I'm also eclectic in terms of taste like you. One of my favorite things about music is that I love finding new artists. Hunting for great sounds has kind of become a hobby with all the new technology. This is a very useful tool for that.

"Mike"Fri, 12/2/05 1:31pm

WOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOW!!!!! Thank you REM, U2, Buddy Holly, Lou Reed, Lucinda Williams, Wilco, Townes Van Zandt, Radiohead, JOhnny Cash, Patsy Cline, Natalie Merchant, Flying Burrito Brothers for bringing me to Incredible String Band and to the Holy Modal Rounders!

ACFri, 12/2/05 1:32pm

P.S. Once I discovered the "minimize" button, I was REALLY hooked.

"Mike"Fri, 12/2/05 1:39pm

WOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOW!!!!! Thank you REM, U2, Buddy Holly, Lou Reed, Lucinda Williams, Wilco, Townes Van Zandt, Radiohead, Johnny Cash, Patsy Cline, Natalie Merchant, Flying Burrito Brothers for bringing me to Incredible String Band and to the Holy Modal Rounders!

Jeff TidballFri, 12/2/05 1:42pm

Holy fucking wow.

"Unfuckingbelievable is right" is right.

BrandonFri, 12/2/05 1:56pm

Good call on the minimize button, AC!

BrandonSat, 12/3/05 5:31pm

Okay, so, uh, I'm feeling pretty stupid right about now. Christi has a subscription to the business magazine Fast Company, and the December issue has been in the house for about a week or two. And today, as I'm cleaning up, I notice this splashed across the very top:

"Pandora: The Genius Fix for iTunes"

And a nice little feature article inside. D'oh! I even read part of the magazine when it first arrived because there was a cover story on technological advances in Hollywood, but failed to notice the Pandora feature (not that Pandora would have meant anything to me two weeks ago, but the iTunes reference should've drawn my interest).

One thing the feature mentioned was that Pandora was only free for a 10-hour preview, and after that you have to subscribe. Jameson or AC - you guys have been using it the longest, have you encountered an end to the free service?

Anonymous CowardSat, 12/3/05 11:52pm

I was into Itunes long before you were.

Bee BoySun, 12/4/05 12:08am

I listened most of Friday and didn't experience an end to the service – but I probably didn't exceed 10 hours. At one point, I was informed that the license agreement prohibits me from skipping more than a certain number of tracks per hour, but that's all. (And that was kind of encouraging, because it implied the record labels were in on this and saw the benefit of getting their music before an audience.)

Your Comments
Name: OR Log in / Register to comment
e-mail:

Comments: (show/hide formatting tips)

send me e-mail when new comments are posted

onebee